There are really only five black quarterbacks that regularly started games this season (I’m counting RGIII, Newton, Wilson, Vick, and Freeman). Those five ranked 1, 2, 3, 5, 15 respectively in rushing but 22, 13, 23, 27, and 9 in passing. Obviously black quarterbacks rush for more than white but when their are only five of them to win a superbowl versus 27 white guys. Of those five, RG3 and Wilson made the playoffs which is actually good.

Really of the past 11 years a black quarterback should have won 2 super bowls and been playing in 4 given the ratio of starting whites/blacks. But in the years you listed there’s only 1 black quarterback on the losing side (McNabb). 1 out of 22 isn’t quite equal to the 5/32 so apparently the white QBs have more success by a good bit than black QBs.

It seems like the running quarterback is a pain in the ass for defenses but isn’t actually going to get you anywhere besides maybe a first round playoff loss (or win if you’re playing the only other black rushing QB in the playoffs).